|
Enthusiast Tackle: Reel Review |
The Makings of an Import Legend - the Shimano Scorpion
1000/1001
Date: |
11/22/04 |
Tackle type: |
Reels |
Manufacturer: |
Shimano
Japan |
Reviewer: |
Cal |
Total Score: 8.75
Introduction:
For many tackle enthusiasts, it all starts here, the Shimano Scorpion 1000/1001.
Sharing its heritage with the ever popular US Market Shimano Curado, the
Scorpion 1000 has become the benchmark of what an import reel has to offer.
Discussion forums throughout the internet praise this reel’s value and
performance, and at online auction houses, despite the reel’s import status,
sales are closed almost daily. Just what is it that makes this reel so popular?
Could it be its color? Maybe its unique brake adjustment? How about its titanium
coated perforated spool? We here at TackleTour have taken the Shimano Scorpion
1000 series to the task to share with you what we think about this very popular
little reel.
Shimano
Scorpion
Specifications |
Line Capacity (lb/yds) |
12/109 |
Gear Ratio (actual retrieve) |
6.2:1 (22 inches per turn) |
Weight (actual measured) |
8.1 oz. (8.2 oz or 233 grams) |
Bearings |
4BB + 1RB |
Additional Features |
4x4 SVS, Titanium
coated SIC line guide, Titanium Coated Duralumin Spool, contoured knobs for
left and right hand retrieve. |
MSRP |
~$160.00 |
Impressions: The
first thing that strikes you when opening the box of this Scorpion reel is its
color and it seems to be one of those dividing points of discussion meaning you
either hate it or you love it. Considering this color can be likened to a deep
burgundy Bordeaux that’s been aging in the cellars of a tried and true wine
producer, we here at TT rather enjoy this unique finish on a fishing reel. Then,
naturally, as you pull the reel out of it’s hold, the reflex reaction is to
click the freespool over and give that titanium coated perforated spool a whirl.
It does not disappoint spinning freely and effortlessly for a good seven to
eight seconds. The biggest challenge after all this initial inspection, is
finding a rod to compliment this intriguing import from Shimano Japan.
|
The Scorpion
100/1001's unique color is just one of its many endearing qualities |
Field Tests:
We loaded this reel up on a variety of rods and with a variety of lines in order
to determine what felt best. What we settled on for testing purposes was 10lb Yozuri Hybrid and a Kistler Helium LTA He70MC. This combination weighed in at a
respectable 11.8 ounces, and really served to compliment each other well. Next,
we took to our favorite fishing spots in
Northern California
to see what this almost legendary reel had to offer.
|
Matched with
our Kistler Helium LTA He70MC, the Scorpion proved to be a very comfortable
reel to palm |
Casting/Pitching: True to
the hyperbole, our Scorpion 1001 was a very easy casting and pitching reel. The
externally adjustable 4x4SVS brake system is a welcome departure from Shimano’s
covered sideplate, and the reel manages to launch any variety of offerings
smoothly and effortlessly even into the wind. In our tests, we were able to cast
everything from split shot rigs using a 3/0 weight and #2 light wire hook to
three quarter ounce lipless cranks all with relative ease. But perhaps our
favorite offerings with the Scorpion were weightless plastics such as the Zoom
Horny Toad and Yamamoto Senko. Not once were we disappointed by the Scorpion’s
casting performance and we were even more impressed by how well the reel
facilitates pitching presentations.
|
Among the
features of the Scorpion 1000/1001 are an externally adjustable cast control
system, titanium coated perforated spool, contoured septon grips, and micro
click adjustable drag |
Retrieving:
The Scorpion is a very smooth retrieving reel. The contoured septon grips,
though not bearing supported, still provide an amazingly comfortable form and
texture to grip while turning the handle. The handle itself is 70mm in length. A
size we found sufficient for working plastics, but too small for working moving
baits such as cranks, spinners and buzzbaits. The shorter length simply does not
provide sufficient torque for working these types of baits all day long. There
are a number of options for installing compatible 80 and 85 mm handles including
taking the handle off of a Chronarch SF, but it would far less complicated if a
standard length handle were an option from the beginning. Lastly, the infinite
anti-reverse on the Scorpion is another area in need of improvement. Holding the
spool down with one’s thumb, you can feel quite a bit of play in the handle.
This play never became an issue while fishing with the reel, but is simply a
gauge we like to use to get an idea of the engineering tolerances associated
with the reel’s design. The Scorpion is obviously not a top end import reel,
nevertheless, we’ve come to expect more when purchasing the name Shimano.
|
The
Scorpion 1000/1001 sports attractive contours including a front design
reminiscent of a stylish auto |
Drag:
Another area that can use improvement is the Scorpion’s drag. Though sporting
the classic Shimano smoothness, the actual strength of the drag is a mere three
pounds of maximum drag pressure as measured in our lab. Though sufficient for
finesse applications, we found this amount of pressure lacking when fishing
horizontal baits. To compensate for this low amount of drag pressure, we
resorted to clamping our thumbs down on the spool during hooksets and while
fighting hard charging fish. On the brighter side of things, the actual drag
adjustment is enhanced with the classic micro-click adjustment often reserved
for higher end reels.
|
Refinements
such as a pivoting sideplate, cast aluminum spool tension knob, aluminum
handle with septon grips are often refinements only found on costlier reels |
Ergonomics and
Design:
The Scorpion 1000
series reel has a comfortable low profile design that is easily palmed even by
those with the smallest of hands. The sideplate of this reel flips open and
pivots away easily, staying attached to the reel and facilitating easy access to
the titanium coated perforated spool. The finish on the reel itself is a
metallic burgundy paint that is moderately durable. Scratches and scuffs are
somewhat disguised with this finish since the underlying color is black. Though
constructed entirely of aluminum, one thing the painted finish does do is give
the angler a sense that the reel is constructed of plastic rather than a
lightweight metal. Because of this, the reel does not feel as refined and solid
as it should.
Ratings:
Shimano
Scorpion Ratings
(?/10) |
Construction/Quality |
Solidly constructed though
lacking those refinements to give one a sense it is a real solid reel |
8.5 |
Performance |
Casting performance can be
likened to reels costing twice as much, however drag performance is lacking
sufficient power for a multi purpose reel |
8 |
Price |
Attractively priced
especially given its import status |
9.5 |
Features |
The best feature of this
reel is the external 4x4 SVS brake adjustment - a feature we would welcome
on all Shimano Reels |
9 |
Design (Ergonomics) |
A very attractive reel
that is comfortable to palm and easy to use – except for the short, 70mm
handle |
9 |
Application |
With an upgraded standard
length handle and slightly stronger drag, this reel could be used for most
anything related to freshwater fishing. As such, it is better suited for
finesse applications or other slow, methodic presentations. |
8.5 |
Total Score |
8.75 |
Pluses and Minuses:
Plus Minus |
J
Casts as well as reels
costing twice as much |
L
Drag more suited for
finesse applications |
J
Externally adjustable
cast control system |
L
Short handle |
J
Very comfortable
profile |
L
Finish gives the reel
a plastic feel |
J
Comfortable septon
grips |
L
Anti-reverse is not
quite infinite |
J
Reasonable price point |
|
Conclusion: Lacking
some of the refinements of other higher priced import offerings, yet teasing you
with some of the same performance characteristics of those reels, we found the
Scorpion 1000/1001 reel a good value overall and an excellent choice for someone
just sinking their teeth into the enthusiast market. Of its shortcomings, we
find the lack of a standard length handle the most frustrating and the first
item likely to receive attention from those purchasing this reel to support
horizontal bait presentations. Aside from that, while the micro-click adjustable
drag hints at ultra-fine refinements, the easy casting performance and
availability of an externally adjustable cast control are the true benefits of
this reel. It’s not hard to see why this reel has such a following and why it
has reached near legendary status in all the online discussion forums.
|
|
|
|