Near Ultimate Spinning Shootout - Shimano Sustain Versus Daiwa TD-S

Date: |
1/2/02 |
Tackle type: |
Reels |
Manufacturer: |
Shimano,
Daiwa |
Reviewer: |
Team TT |
Introduction: Both Shimano and Daiwa have an extensive line of reels
ranging from affordable to premium. Many Anglers dream about fishing with the
Stella or Team Daiwa-Z, but the price of $500 dollars for this experience is
astronomical. For the rest of us there are the Sustain and TD-S. These reels are
the next in line in both of the reel giant's lineups. We put these two reels
head to head to find out who is the king of "near ultimate spinning!"
Shimano
Sustain (2000) Specifications |
Line Capacity |
6/170;8/120;10/100 |
Gear Ratio |
5.2:1 |
Weight |
10.3 (oz) |
Bearings |
5BB, 1RB |
Additional Features |
Aluminum body, Aluminum Titanium lipped spare spool included, Super Stopper
II, Dynabalance, Fluidrive II, Power Roller |
MSRP |
$229.00 |
Daiwa TD-S
(2000) Specifications |
Line Capacity |
6/135;8/110;10/90 |
Gear Ratio |
4.8:1 |
Weight |
9.7 (oz) |
Bearings |
5BB, 1RB |
Additional Features |
Aluminum frame, ABS aluminum spare spool included, Air Bail, Twist Buster 2,
Gyro Spin, Infinite Anti Reverse, One touch folding handle, comes with a
Daiwa reel bag |
MSRP |
$184.95 |
Impressions: Both of these reels employ the best technologies that the
manufacturers have to offer. In fact the only thing that separates them from the
premium Stella and TDZ are the number of bearings, weight, and price.
You can tell just by looking at both reels that they are premium. Both are
completely aluminum with gold and titanium dressing, and it is difficult to find
a single piece of plastic on either one. The reels both have a very different stance
and profile.
The Sustain looks sleek and sharp with a slender body, and narrow titanium
lipped spool, and a pointed silver toned drag adjustment. In comparison the TDS
is short and wider due to the enlarged ABS spool and compact body.
The Comparison:
Observations and setup: For these tests we first spent hours
comparing the two reels in the lab from a technological point of view, as well
as logging in over 20hrs fishing time with each reel. We paired both reels with
a GLoomis single piece 6'6" rod (SJR783), and 8lb Trilene XL for our field
tests.
Note: In reality the Daiwa TD-S is .6oz lighter then the Shimano, but for this
test we used one size larger TD-S 2500 because the handle was much more to our
liking and comparable to the Sustain. All the Daiwa TD-S's below 2500 use the
smaller single digit handle.
Casting: The Daiwa TD-S was the easier reel to cast long
distances. The main reason for this was the ABS spool which allowed us to use up
every last millimeter of the spool, up to the edge. The increased size of the
spool facilitates a more generous amount of line is given per cast simply
because there are fewer rotations of line necessary to
be released. Daiwa
claims this design also reduces the number of line tangles caused by excessive
loops on normal spools.
 |
The Sustain
features a unique handle lever and a comfortable wooden handle |
Casting the Sustain was also easy and after time we could feel the difference in
cast smoothness over the standard Shimano reels due to the titanium lipped
aluminum spool.
Both reels were compact enough that we could easily hold the rod and still have
maximum line control with the extension of just the index finger.
 |
The
Sustain's titanium lipped spool makes extended casting easy |
The Retrieve: Both these reels utilize the same number of bearings but
the cranking on each reel feels very different. The Sustain is smoother on
retrieves while the Daiwa feels more muscular, partly due to its gear ratio.
While the Daiwa TD-S was able to retrieve lures quickly the Sustain was
definitely the quieter reel.
The Sustain features an internal bail reset while the Daiwa has an external bail
switch. If you look carefully at the Daiwa TD-S you will notice when the bail is
open a small black switch protrudes out of the back of the aluminum rotor and
must physically come in contact with the body in order to reset the bail to the
closed position. This means that the bail must sometimes travel a full rotation
before it is reset, and depending on what point the rotor is resting will
determine how much pressure is necessary to physically reset the bail. Of course
if you are in the habit of closing the bail by hand after each cast this will
not effect you.
The Sustain features a more conventional bail while the TD-S uses a similar bail
found in their top of the line TD-Z which is the patented "Air Bail." The "Air
Bail" is enlarged and hollow, and has a titanium nitride finish. Because the
bail is protrusion free loose line cannot be snagged. (Interesting to note that
the higher end Shimano Stella features a similar bail design)
Both Reels utilize technology to eliminate back play in the handle completely,
and both lived up to this claim. You can be sure that for every hook set both
these reels are solid and have absolutely no give in the rotor.
 |
The
Daiwa TD-S features a titanium "Air Bail" and a easy one switch foldable
handle |
The Drag: Both in the lab and in the field with equal pressure applied to
both reels, the Daiwa TD-S proved to have the superior drag. The TD-S produces
the smoothest performance with almost no fade and also beat the Sustain in terms
of adjustment. The TD-S was much better at being tightened in very small
increments, where as we had to rotate the Shimano Drag much further for desired
settings. The TD-S also makes a more harmonious "pinging" sound rather then
"clicks" when the drag is engaged at high speed.
 |
The Daiwa
TD-S features a incredibly precise drag adjustment |
The Details:
Shimano Sustain: The Sustain is the
sleeker sexier reel with all of the features found in Shimano's reliable line
including super stopper II, Dynabalance, and Fluidrive. What makes the Sustain
so incredibly smooth is Shimano's "Floating Shaft" system which supports the
spool shaft with multiple ball bearings. The handle of the Shimano Sustain is
beautiful and a unique statement in itself, and the reduced bulk only adds to
the sleek thin profile of the Sustain. Shimano also adds an extra aluminum spool
into the package.
Daiwa TD-S: The Team Daiwa-S is just
as beautiful and functional as the Sustain but is a much more angular bulky
reel, but looks and feels more powerful. While not as smooth as the Sustain, the
TD-S is an excellent caster and features an incredible drag system. The inclusion
of the "Air Bail" makes the TD-S even more appealing, and connects it to its big
brother the TD-Z. Daiwa sweetens the package with an extra aluminum spool, a
Daiwa protective reel bag, and a one touch foldable handle.
Shimano Sustain Ratings:
Shimano
Sustain Ratings (?/10) |
Construction/Quality |
Great construction, and good choice of
materials, especially the titanium lipped aluminum spool |
9 |
Performance |
Performance is excellent, and the smoothness
of this reel can even compete with the Stella which retails for 489.00! |
9 |
Price |
Definitely a premium reel, and Shimano charges
229.00 for the opportunity to fish with one. This is over 100 dollars over
the next in line Stradic |
8.5 |
Features |
Good features that set the Sustain apart from
the rest of the family, including its titanium lipped spool and unique
handle. |
8.5 |
Design (Ergonomics) |
The ergonomic handle and super slim
construction make it a easy reel to fish with. We were surprised it weighed
10.3oz, it looks like it should weigh less then 9oz! |
9 |
Application |
A good reel for every occasion the Sustain can
be used in fresh or saltwater with no problem (though we would reserve it
for freshwater finesse fishing) |
10 |
Total Score |
9 |
Daiwa TD-S Ratings:
Daiwa Team
Daiwa-S Ratings (?/10) |
Construction/Quality |
Great quality that is a big step up from the
now updated SSII line. The construction is rock solid and the Daiwa is as
tough as it looks...but is surprisingly light! |
9 |
Performance |
Performance of the casting and drag are
incredible. We have never seen a reel that you can make such minor and
effective drag adjustments. |
9 |
Price |
Daiwa charges a reasonable price for the TD-S
(184.95) which is only 40 dollars more then the next in line SSII, its great
to see a premium reel like this under 200 dollars |
9 |
Features |
All the features of a premium reel plus a
folding handle, and a unique Air Bail that not only is a smooth performer on
the water but will get your friends talking. Extra value features like ABS
spool, folding handle, and carry bag a plus! |
9.5 |
Design (Ergonomics) |
The TD-S isn't the most elegant looking reel
but the design is one of perfect function, and the ABS spool and compact
body make for easy fishing |
9 |
Application |
Great for every occasion the TD-S is strong
enough to tackle almost any fish with style |
10 |
Total Score |
9.25 |
Pluses and Minuses:
Reel Comparison Pluses and
Minuses |
Shimano
Sustain |
Plus
Minus |
J
Beautiful streamline design |
L
Price is high |
J
Reliable performance |
L
Refinement of drag
|
J
Titanium lipped spool |
L
Weight could be less |
J
Spare Spool |
|
J
Ultra smooth |
|
Daiwa Team
Daiwa-S |
Plus
Minus |
J
Reasonable Price |
L
Could be smoother |
J
Perfect Drag |
L
External bail reset system |
J
"Air Bail" |
L
Small handle in sub2500 models |
J
Spare Spool |
|
J
Lightweight |
|
J
ABS Spool for casting |
|
Conclusion: These are both incredible reels and picking a winner was
extremely difficult. Both are on opposite ends of the spectrum in terms of
design. While the Sustain is sleek and sexy the TD-S is muscular and aggressive,
both offer great features that live up to the claims of premium performance.
Ultimately the Daiwa TD-S wins the title of "Near Ultimate Spinning" thanks to a
lower price and added value features that not only set it apart from the
Sustain, but all the other reels on the market. The patented Daiwa "Air Bail"
and "ABS" spool are added value innovations that increase the performance and
value of the Team Daiwa-S.
Until next time....Tight Lines!
